NCERT Solutions: Forms of Business Organisation
I. Short Answer Questions
In a JHF business, a minor gains membership by virtue of birth. There is no requirement for a contract or age of majority to enter the family business. The minor becomes a "Co-parcener" and holds an equal interest in the ancestral property. Crucially, the liability of a minor in JHF is restricted only to their share in the business property.
Partnership Firm:According to the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, a partnership arises from a contract; since a minor is incompetent to contract, they cannot be a full-fledged partner. However, a minor can be admitted to the "benefits" of an existing partnership with the mutual consent of all partners. They share profits but are not liable for business debts beyond their capital contribution.
While the law does not make registration compulsory, an unregistered firm suffers from several legal disabilities that make operation risky.
Disadvantages of Non-Registration:- Suing Third Parties: An unregistered firm cannot file a lawsuit against any third party for breach of contract.
- Inter-Partner Disputes: Partners cannot seek legal recourse against one another or the firm in case of internal conflicts.
- Settlement of Claims: The firm cannot claim a "set-off" in a court of law if sued by a creditor for an amount exceeding ₹100.
A private company can be incorporated with only two members, whereas a public company requires a minimum of seven.
2. Simplified Management:It is only required to have two directors, compared to the three required by public companies, making decision-making more agile.
3. Immediate Commencement:A private company can start its business operations immediately after obtaining the Certificate of Incorporation, bypassing the lengthy process of obtaining a Certificate of Commencement required by public firms.
Cooperatives function on the principle of "One Member, One Vote." Regardless of the amount of capital contributed, every member has an equal voice in electing the managing committee. This prevents the concentration of power in the hands of the wealthy.
Secular Foundations:Membership is open to all individuals regardless of their religion, caste, creed, or gender. This "Open Membership" policy ensures that the society remains a secular platform dedicated solely to the economic welfare of its members.
A Partner by Estoppel is an individual who is not a partner in the firm but, through their conduct, words, or behavior, leads others to believe that they are a partner.
Legal Implications:Even though they do not contribute capital or share profits, they are held personally liable for the debts of the firm to any third party who extended credit based on that false representation. Their private assets can be seized to settle such claims.
II. Long Answer Questions
This is a form of organization owned, managed, and controlled by a single individual who is the recipient of all profits and the bearer of all risks.
Merits of Sole Proprietorship:- Quick Decision Making: The owner enjoys complete freedom and does not need to consult others, allowing for rapid responses to market changes.
- Direct Incentive: The direct link between effort and reward (all profits) motivates the owner to work at peak efficiency.
- Confidentiality: There is no legal requirement to publish accounts, keeping business secrets safe.
- Limited Resources: Capital is restricted to the personal savings and borrowing capacity of one person.
- Unlimited Liability: If the business fails, the owner's personal assets can be sold to pay off business debts.
- Limited Managerial Ability: One person cannot be an expert in sales, finance, purchasing, and marketing simultaneously.
Choosing a business form is a critical decision that impacts long-term survival. The following factors must be evaluated:
1. Capital Requirements:If the business requires huge investment (like a steel plant), a Company form is best. For small-scale local shops, Sole Proprietorship is sufficient.
2. Degree of Liability:Where risks are high, entrepreneurs prefer the Limited Liability offered by a Company or Cooperative. If the owner is willing to take personal risk, they may choose a Partnership.
3. Continuity and Stability:If the business needs to last beyond the life of the owner (Perpetual Succession), a Company is the only viable choice.
4. Managerial Needs:Large operations requiring professional experts are best suited for the Company structure, which can afford to hire specialized managers.
| Basis of Comparison | Joint Hindu Family (JHF) | Partnership |
|---|---|---|
| Governing Law | Hindu Succession Act | Indian Partnership Act, 1932 |
| Membership | By birth in the family. | By mutual agreement/contract. | }
| Number of Members | Min: 2; Max: No limit. | Min: 2; Max: 100. |
| Liability | Karta has unlimited liability; others have limited. | All partners have unlimited liability. |
| Minor Status | Minor is a member by birth. | Minor only admitted for benefits. |
III. Application & Case Studies
Neha is a successful sole proprietor of an artificial jewelry retail chain. She is considering converting her business into a Joint Stock Company to manage her nationwide expansion plans.
Why move to a Joint Stock Company?Converting to a company will allow Neha to raise vast amounts of capital by issuing shares to the public. It also provides Limited Liability, meaning her personal jewelry and house will not be at risk if the expansion fails. This structure is essential for "going nationwide" as it provides a professional management framework and permanent stability.
Legal Formalities for Incorporation:To operate as a company, Neha must go through the following stages:
- Promotion: Identifying the business opportunity.
- Documentation: Preparing the Memorandum of Association (MoA) and Articles of Association (AoA).
- Registration: Filing these documents with the Registrar of Companies to get the Certificate of Incorporation.
No comments:
Post a Comment